Academy Disqualifies Four Great Score Contenders

According to Variety, the scores for Black Swan, True Grit, The Kids Are Alright and The Fighter will not be eligible to compete this year. Clint Mansell‘s Black Swan score and Carter Burwell‘s True Grit score were disqualified attributed to a designation within Rule 16 of the Academy’s Special Rules for Music Awards (5d under “Eligibility”), which excludes “scores diluted by the use of tracked themes or other pre-existing music.” Meanwhile, the scores for The Kids Are All Right, also by Carter Burwell, and The Fighter, by Michael Brook, were deemed ineligible because the music is “diminished in impact by the predominant use of songs.”

Now while I understand that Mansell’s Black Swan was largely adapted from Tchaikovsky’s Swan Lake, and Carter Burwell’s True Grit is mostly based on 19th century hymns, I don’t understand why the other two won’t qualify. Regardless if the scores to The Kids Are All Right and The Fighter play second fiddle to a heavy soundtrack, they are still original works and the voters should be allowed to decide based on the quality and not length of the score.

Looking back at our list of best scores from 2010, it seems the following five contenders have the best chance in being nominated and possibly winning:

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part I

Tron: Legacy

Let Me In

The Social Network

Never Let Me Go

Please like us on Facebook

By Ricky

Some people take my heart, others take my shoes, and some take me home. I write, I blog, I podcast and I edit. RIcky is the Editor-in-Chief of Sound On Sight and the host of several podcasts including Nxpress (Nintendo podcast), Game of Thrones, True Detective and Walking Dead shows, as well as the Sound On Sight flagship and Sordid Cinema podcast. He is Sound On Sight's expert on Horror and Nintendo and teaches at an elementary school in Montreal.

Follow on Twitter

Connect on Facebook

View all Posts

Visit Website

Share This Post



2 Responses to Academy Disqualifies Four Great Score Contenders

  1. Kaitlin McNabb December 27, 2010 at 8:33 pm

    this definitely sucks since Black Swan is such an amazing score. The rules make valid points, but who says original art cannot be made from preexisting material? Also, how many movies are created from previous material, books, tv, original movies and still given full credit? Seems unfair.

  2. Peter December 26, 2010 at 5:36 am

    I guess inception is ineligible too, shame coz the score was one of it’s strongest points


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *